UK Car Insurance Articles
search advanced search

Home >> Car Insurance Articles

A closer look at the new motor insurance gender equality rules

Article by Simon Christopher
Article added: 4/3/2011 - Last updated: -
Rating: 5.00 5.00 (3 votes)

car insurance equalityFollowing a ruling by the European Court of Justice, UK insurers will not be allowed to use gender as a factor when setting insurance premiums.

That should mean in theory that a man and a woman whose application details are otherwise identical should pay the same premium. Insurers have been given until 21 December 2012 to change their procedures so they can follow these rules.

Who made the rules?

The change came from a case in the European Court of Justice. It ruled on a long-standing dispute about how existing European law, which bars price discrimination on gender grounds, should affect insurance. This measure is already part of British law, but national governments (including Britain) will no longer be allowed to have an exception for insurance after 2012. The odd date is because this is exactly five years after countries were required to change domestic laws on price discrimination.

Why is this so important for motor insurance?

Motor insurance is the area of insurance where there is the biggest difference between genders. This is down to statistical evidence that women are less likely to make expensive claims than men. What many people don't realise is that the difference isn't simply how likely a person is to make a claim, but also how costly that claim will be: to grossly oversimplify, it's more likely that a woman will have a minor prang while a man is more likely to have a crash with a complete write-off.

How will this affect premiums?

This is difficult to say. In theory insurers will have to find new profitable premium levels for both genders. This will almost certainly mean that, with the same insurer at least, women will on average see price rises and men see price falls. Exactly how prices change may depend on the competition in the market and how consumers respond: for example, if prices for women's car insurance leap up, they may switch to third party, fire and theft policies rather than comprehensive policies.

Will everyone be affected equally?

It's unlikely. The current price differential is far greater among younger drivers than older drivers, meaning it's young drivers who should see the biggest difference.

What other changes could result?

One likelihood is that insurers will put more emphasis on other factors such as the type of car driven or the driver's occupation to take more account of individual risk. It's also possible some insurers will simply stop offering policies to younger drivers, which could reduce competition.

Does this affect any other form of insurance?

Yes, it should mean life assurance costs change. Because women live longer on average, they currently tend to pay lower premiums -- the logic being that they will be paying premiums for longer so the total amount received by insurers theoretically works out the same. The ruling should also mean reduced premiums for men and increased premiums for women.

So it's all good news for men then?

Not entirely. The rules also cover annuities, which are the financial products people buy with their retirement savings to produce future pensions. At the moment if a man and a woman have the same amount to spend on an annuity, the man will receive a higher pension as he is expected to receive it for a shorter time before dying; after the changes they'll have to get the same amount. However, the effects of this change may not be all that noticeable as they could be outweighed by other factors affecting all annuities more drastically in the coming years.

PLEASE NOTE: The guidance published in this article is for information only and does not constitute financial advice or a recommendation of any particular car insurance product or company. If you are in any doubt please consult an independent insurance adviser. A database of advisers in your area is available at

Copyright UK Insurance Index All rights reserved.

comments about this car insurance article

Comments About this Article:

 Add a Comment

share this car insurance article

Share this Article:

rate this car insurance article

Rate this Article:

Please rate this article between 0 and 5
with 5 being top.
All ratings received for this article.

all categories ALL CATEGORIES
A-Z Categories

popular categories POPULAR CATEGORIES
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Cover
Mobile Phone Cover
Pet Insurance
Travel Insurance

directory categories DIRECTORY CATEGORIES
Home & Property
Insurance Brokers
Life & Protection
Non UK Insurers
Pet & Animal
Personal Possessions
Specialist Cover

review categories REVIEW CATEGORIES
Car & Motor
Insurance Companies
Life Cover
Pet & Animal

article categories ARTICLE CATEGORIES
Car & Motor
Home & Property
Insurance Awards
Insurance Guides
Life Cover
Pet & Animal

news categories NEWS CATEGORIES
Business News
Car and Motor News
General News
Health News
Home & Property News
Life Cover News
Pet and Animal News
Travel News


Direct Line Car Insurance
Direct Line
Direct Line offers a range of big policy benefits like vandalism cover and named driver no-claims bonuses which are only available direct.

latest listings LATEST LISTINGS
Octagon Insurance
Quote Me Happy Car Insurance
RSA echoice car insurance
Your Cover Car Insurance from Allianz
Autonet Car Insurance - up to 60% off

latest reviews LATEST REVIEWS
Heritage Classic Car Insurance
Age UK Car Insurance
Carole Nash Bike Insurance
1st Central Car Insurance
One Quote Direct Car Insurance

latest articles LATEST ARTICLES
Getting the best value GAP insurance
5 mistakes that could instantly void your car insurance policy
Is your job title increasing your car insurance premiums?
A closer look at the new compulsory motor insurance rules
A closer look at the new motor insurance gender equality rules

Home | Privacy & Cookies | Terms of Use | Contact |

Page protected, do not copy

This website uses cookies to ensure a reliable browsing experience. If you continue to use this website you are consenting to us using cookies in this way. To find out what cookies are, which ones we use and why we use them please click here.

Copyright © 2019 UK Insurance Index. All rights reserved.
All directory listings, articles and reviews are provided as information only and do not constitute advice or a recommendation of any product or provider. If you use these insurers, we take no responsibility and give no guarantees, warranties or representations, implied or otherwise, for the content or accuracy of these third-party web sites or companies. If you have any doubts you should consult an authorised independent financial adviser for advice based upon your individual needs and circumstances. A database of advisers in your area is available at