UK Home Insurance Articles
search advanced search

Home >> Home Insurance Articles

Home insurance complaints what you can learn from others misfortune

Article by Simon Christopher
Article added: 22/4/2012 - Last updated: -
Rating: 4.00 4.00 (1 votes)

home insurance claimWhile most home insurance cases are clear-cut, there are occasions when the insurer and the customer disagree. This can often lead to complaints to the Financial Ombudsman, which investigates the case. While the Financial Ombudsman doesn't write the law, the organisation's decisions can give insight into what is and is not considered reasonable and fair behavior by an insurer.

Here are some of the more notable cases highlighted over the past couple of years in the organisation's publication "ombudsman news" and the lessons customers can learn.

Storm Damage

The heavy storms of late 2011 led to numerous claims and in turn several complaints. The key findings from five cases examined by the Ombudsman are as follows:

A customer who was redecorating their home had kept possessions in a temporary marquee in the garden. Although this wasn't necessarily unreasonable in itself, the claim was rejected because the customer didn't tell the insurer the possessions were now being stored outside, which was a significant change in circumstances.

A customer claimed for water damage after their roof leaked. The claim was rejected because it appeared the damage was caused by ongoing wet weather rather than a single storm. Another case involved a wall collapsing after heavy rainfall, but the claim was rejected because the wall had been deteriorating over time and would likely have remained standing had it been in good condition. A third case involved guttering that had collapsed after a week of heavy snowfall, which the insurer rejected as ongoing bad weather rather than a storm. In all three cases the key is that insurance policies only cover individual events, not ongoing activity.

An insurer refused to pay out for wind damage because the gusts hadn't reached a set speed (level 10 on the Beaufort scale, or 55 miles per hour.) The ombudsman ruled that the insurer should have paid out and said the deciding factor was the effects of the storm, not its measured strength.

Automatic Renewals

A student complained after an insurer automatically renewed their contents policy and continued taking monthly payments, despite the student having moved abroad for a work placement. The ombudsman ordered the insurer to repay the premiums and cancel the policy. Although automatic renewal clauses such as those included in the policy are legal, the ombudsman decided this one had not been made clear enough to the customer.


An insurance company refused to pay for a customer to have a lost custom-made ring replaced by the original jeweller, instead offering only to pay for a jeweller of the insurance company's choice to make a replacement (at a lower cost.) Although normally insurers have the right to source a replacement, in this case the ombudsman said the unique nature of the ring, made for an anniversary, meant another jeweller's efforts would not be a reasonable replacement.

An insurer refused to replace some expensive items after a burglary as the customer did not have receipts, though the customer had shown photographs of the items in the house and details of a valuation. The ombudsman ordered the insurer to replace them, noting the threshold is merely that the customer show enough evidence "on balance" of ownership.

PLEASE NOTE: The guidance published in this article is for information only and does not constitute financial advice or a recommendation of any particular home insurance policy or company. If you are in any doubt please consult an independent insurance adviser. A database of advisers in your area is available at

Copyright UK Insurance Index All rights reserved.

comments about this home insurance article

Comments About this Article:

 Add a Comment

share this home insurance article

Share this Article:

rate this home insurance article

Rate this Article:

Please rate this article between 0 and 5
with 5 being top.
All ratings received for this article.

all categories ALL CATEGORIES
A-Z Categories

popular categories POPULAR CATEGORIES
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Cover
Mobile Phone Cover
Pet Insurance
Travel Insurance

directory categories DIRECTORY CATEGORIES
Home & Property
Insurance Brokers
Life & Protection
Non UK Insurers
Pet & Animal
Personal Possessions
Specialist Cover

review categories REVIEW CATEGORIES
Car & Motor
Insurance Companies
Life Cover
Pet & Animal

article categories ARTICLE CATEGORIES
Car & Motor
Home & Property
Insurance Awards
Insurance Guides
Life Cover
Pet & Animal

news categories NEWS CATEGORIES
Business News
Car and Motor News
General News
Health News
Home & Property News
Life Cover News
Pet and Animal News
Travel News

Churchill Home Insurance
Churchill Home Insurance
Award winning home insurance company with comprehensive features and price guarantee.

latest listings LATEST LISTINGS
UKinsuranceNet Home Insurance
Age Co Home Insurance
Protect Your Bubble Home Insurance - 25 cash back*
Policy Expert Home Insurance Comparison
Staysure Home Insurance

latest reviews LATEST REVIEWS
Domestic and General Washing Machine Cover
Key Connect Home Insurance
Warranty Shop Home Appliance Cover
RIAS Contents Cover
Homeserve Boiler Cover

latest articles LATEST ARTICLES
Home insurance complaints what you can learn from others misfortune
What happens when an insurer won't pay your home insurance claim
Home contents insurance - limit your risk with the right cover limit
Are you a victim of the home insurance postcode lottery?
Will a flood leave your home insurance high and dry?

Home | Privacy & Cookies | Terms of Use | Contact |

Page protected, do not copy

This website uses cookies to ensure a reliable browsing experience. If you continue to use this website you are consenting to us using cookies in this way. To find out what cookies are, which ones we use and why we use them please click here.

Copyright © 2019 UK Insurance Index. All rights reserved.
All directory listings, articles and reviews are provided as information only and do not constitute advice or a recommendation of any product or provider. If you use these insurers, we take no responsibility and give no guarantees, warranties or representations, implied or otherwise, for the content or accuracy of these third-party web sites or companies. If you have any doubts you should consult an authorised independent financial adviser for advice based upon your individual needs and circumstances. A database of advisers in your area is available at